Leadership Mindset
Six Shifts in Thinking From Senior Manager to Executive

The key insight:

The habits that made you excellent at running a function are the ones the executive seat quietly stops rewarding. Nobody tells you which ones.

Searches for leadership mindset return a great deal of encouragement and very little that a director could use on Monday. This page is deliberately plainer. It sets out six shifts in thinking that the step from senior manager to executive tends to demand, and for each one it gives the old habit, the new habit and a test of whether you have made the change.

None of the six is about personality. Each is a habit that earned your last promotion and then quietly stops earning the next one. That is why they are hard to see from inside, and why an outside read helps. If you want one, you can take the free Leadership Psychometric, a 50-question leadership profile that scores five dimensions, and read the six shifts alongside it.

What mindset means here, and what it does not

By mindset we mean working assumptions: what you believe your job is, and therefore what you spend your time on and how you decide. It is not a trait list. Our guide to why a list of leadership qualities is unfalsifiable covers that separate question. It is also not a plan for the first few months in a new seat, which is the subject of the first 90 days of a leadership transition. This page is about the thinking underneath both.

The shifts matter because the public-sector evidence for them is concrete. The Civil Service describes what is expected at each grade through its behaviours, and the Director and Director General examples differ from the Deputy Director ones in a particular way: they move from weighing pressures and recommending an option towards shaping the department's role, engaging senior leaders across government and defending unpopular decisions at the highest level. The work changes character, not just size.

The six shifts at a glance

Shift 1: from doing to deciding through others

The old habit: you are the best at the work, so when it matters you step in. This is how you got promoted, and the team learned to wait for you.

The new habit: you decide what only you can decide and arrange for everything else to be decided well without you. That means setting the criteria, the boundaries and the information you need, then stepping out.

The test: take a week away, or imagine one. If delivery stalls, you have built a team that depends on you, not one that can run. If it holds, ask which of your decisions in the last month were genuinely yours to make. Our guide to delegation skills covers how to hand a decision over without losing the standard.

Shift 2: from being right to being clear

The old habit: you win the argument on the merits. Being right was the currency of the specialist.

The new habit: you make sure a decision is understood and can be carried out by people who were not in the room. A correct decision nobody can restate is not a decision the organisation has made.

The test: ask someone two levels down what was decided last week and why. If they can say it, you were clear. If they can say what, but not why, you were right and incomplete. The Civil Service Director behaviours put the same point in terms of transparency: demonstrate it and create a culture in which others can challenge decisions.

Shift 3: from team loyalty to enterprise view

The old habit: you protect your function's resources, credit and people. At manager level that was a virtue.

The new habit: you treat your function as one part of a system whose results belong to the whole business, and you will sometimes give up something of yours for something that matters more elsewhere.

The test: can you name a trade you made, knowingly, that cost your function and helped the business? If not, you are still defending a perimeter. The same Civil Service behaviours describe Directors building a deep understanding of the department's issues and the wider context. Our guide to stakeholder management skills covers the working methods.

Shift 4: from certainty to judgement under ambiguity

The old habit: you wait until you are sure. In a function with a clear standard, that kept quality high.

The new habit: you decide when the information is incomplete, say what you are assuming and set a point at which you will look again. Executives are rarely paid for certainty, because by the time it arrives the decision has usually been made by someone else.

The test: pick the last decision of consequence. Did you state your assumptions and what would change your mind? If you cannot recall either, you decided on feel and defended it afterwards.

Shift 5: from inherited relationships to designed ones

The old habit: your network is the one the job gave you: your team, your manager, the colleagues you work with daily.

The new habit: you build relationships deliberately, with people outside your reporting line whose support the next role will need. Herminia Ibarra and Mark Hunter, writing in Harvard Business Review, distinguish three kinds of networking: operational, which improves performance on current assignments; personal, which draws on like-minded people outside the organisation; and strategic, which applies networking to business goals and helps a manager spot and seize new opportunities. They call the move to strategic networking a key test of leadership, and note that company programmes usually support only the operational kind, so managers may believe they already network well enough.

The test: list the five people whose backing the next seat depends on. How many are outside your reporting line, and when did you last do something useful for each of them? Our guide to influencing without authority at C-suite level covers the working habits.

Shift 6: from managing your reactions to using your steadiness

The old habit: you control your own reaction, which is a real skill and a necessary one.

The new habit: you recognise that at executive level your steadiness is a signal to others. People read the room from you, and the way you handle an unclear situation tells them how serious it is.

The test: after a tense meeting, ask one person you trust whether they adjusted to you or you adjusted to them. This is where the profile helps most. The Composure dimension reflects how steady you tend to be under pressure, and a combination of high Execution Drive with lower Composure is worth watching, because the drive to act can turn into tightening when the picture is unclear.

Where the five dimensions show your mindset

Mindset acts through tendencies, and the 50-question leadership profile reads five of them. The table links each shift to the dimension where it is most likely to show.

A profile shows tendencies, not destiny, and the evidence from colleagues tells you which way a tendency cuts. If you would like to see what the report covers before creating an account, the Leadership Psychometric overview sets it out. To take it, start with the free Leadership Psychometric.

What the board hears when the mindset has not shifted

The shift matters to those who appoint executives as well as to the leader. In its piece on the chief operating officer role, JOH Partners treats misplaced altitude as a hiring error and warns that a COO who has only ever run one function will struggle beyond it, with the path now running through general-management credibility rather than depth in one discipline. That is the board-side description of shifts 1 to 3.

Making one shift at a time

Do not try to change your outlook. Pick the shift where the test failed most clearly, choose one behaviour that exercises it for a quarter, and ask one person to tell you whether it is working. If the weakest shift is delegation, the behaviour is to hand over one decision completely. If it is enterprise view, it is to make one trade for another function and say so.

Our guide to leadership versus management covers how the weighting moves as you rise, and self-awareness at work covers keeping the habit of checking. The wider Leadership collection covers the rest of what a bigger seat demands.

Key takeaways

• A leadership mindset at executive level is a set of working assumptions about what your job is, and it shows in what you spend time on and how you decide.
• Six shifts recur: doing to deciding through others, being right to being clear, team loyalty to enterprise view, certainty to judgement under ambiguity, inherited to designed relationships, and managing your reactions to using your steadiness.
• Each shift has a test you can run this week, so progress does not depend on how you feel about it.
• The five dimensions of a leadership profile show where each shift is most likely to be hard, and Composure is the one that shows up under ambiguity.
• Change one shift at a time, with one behaviour and one person who will tell you whether it is working.

JOH Partners Intelligence

Get the fortnightly brief on GCC careers, salaries, and market moves.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.