The key insight:
Most senior people think they are good with people because people are polite to them. The better test is whether someone who disagrees with you still says so in the meeting.
Free assessment
Discover your leadership profile
People skills are the everyday behaviours you use to work with and through other people: listening, reading what a room is feeling, giving hard feedback, building trust, disagreeing well and developing others. Early in a career they are a nice extra. At senior level they decide most hiring outcomes, because by then everyone on the shortlist can do the technical job.
This guide is about the behaviours, not the personality behind them. If you want the trait underneath, our piece on emotional intelligence at senior level covers it. Here we look at the six people skills that senior hiring actually tests, how panels and referees check each one, and a short self-check you can run on yourself today.
The higher you go, the less of your work you do yourself. A team leader still produces a lot of output with their own hands. A managing director produces almost nothing directly. Their results come from other people choosing to put in effort, raise problems early and stay.
That shift is visible in the wider labour market too. Economist David Deming's research on the growing importance of social skills found that jobs needing a lot of social interaction grew strongly as a share of US employment between 1980 and 2012, and that the pay premium for social skills rose over the same period. Jobs that needed strong maths but little interaction did worse. That is the general economy. In senior hiring the effect is sharper still.
From the search side, the pattern is simple. When a senior appointment fails, it is rarely because the person could not do the analysis. It is far more often because they lost the trust of their peers, could not get a decision through a resistant team, or drove out the people they needed. JOH Partners has written about the early warning signs of executive derailment, and most of those signs are about people, not plans.
There are many lists of people skills. These six are the ones that come up again and again when we brief clients and take references. Each one is a behaviour that someone else can see and describe.
| People skill | What it looks like at senior level | How a panel checks it | How a referee is asked about it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Listening | You can repeat someone's point back so well that they agree with your version | Asks you to describe a colleague's position you disagreed with | "Did they change their mind when they heard a better argument?" |
| Reading a room | You notice who has gone quiet and who has agreed only in words | Watches how you respond to a panel member who pushes back | "Did they pick up problems before they were said out loud?" |
| Giving hard feedback | You say the difficult thing early, specifically and privately | Asks for an example of feedback that the other person did not want to hear | "When did they last tell you something you did not want to hear?" |
| Building trust across functions | Peers bring you problems early because they expect fair treatment | Asks about a peer relationship that started badly | "Would the other directors back them in a room they were not in?" |
| Disagreeing without damage | You can argue hard and still work well with the person the next day | Asks about a disagreement with your manager or board | "How did they handle it when they lost an argument?" |
| Developing others | People who worked for you have been promoted, inside or outside the company | Asks who you have developed and where they are now | "Who followed them when they moved on?" |
Senior people are often poor listeners for a simple reason. They are used to being right, and they are short of time, so they start forming the answer while the other person is still talking. Good listening at this level is not silence or nodding. It is being able to state the other person's position so accurately that they say, "Yes, that is exactly it." Only then do you answer it.
This is the skill of noticing what has not been said. A chief financial officer who agrees to a plan with one word and then looks at their notes has not agreed. A strong leader picks that up and asks them directly, either in the meeting or straight after it. A weak one takes the word and is surprised three weeks later.
Most managers can give positive feedback. Fewer give difficult feedback early, before the problem has grown. The senior standard is feedback that is specific, private, about behaviour rather than character, and delivered close to the event. If you want practical wording, our feedback examples for managers set out phrasing that works at different levels.
Your own team trusts you partly because you control their pay and promotion. Peers do not have to. Trust across functions is built in small ways: sharing information before you have to, giving credit to another department in front of the chief executive, and never surprising a colleague in a meeting with something you could have told them first.
Research on teams supports this. Amy Edmondson's well-known study of psychological safety and learning in work teams, published in Administrative Science Quarterly, found that teams learn and improve more when members believe they will not be punished for speaking up. Senior leaders set that belief, mostly through how they react the first time someone brings them bad news.
Every senior role involves disagreement with peers, with your manager and sometimes with the board. The question is not whether you disagree but what the relationship looks like afterwards. Strong people argue the point, accept the decision once it is made, and do not reopen it in corridors. The different ways people handle this are set out in our guide to conflict management styles.
This is the most reliable evidence of all, because it leaves a record. Who has worked for you and gone on to bigger roles? Who chose to follow you when you moved? A leader who has never had a direct report promoted, in five or ten years, has a gap that no interview answer will cover.
Senior candidates often expect people skills to be judged on impression. A warm, confident hour with the panel, and the box is ticked. That is rarely how it works.
Panels look for specific examples and then go into the detail. "Tell me about a time you gave feedback that was not welcome" is the start. The follow-up questions are where the score comes from: what exactly did you say, how did they react, what did you do next, and how is that relationship now? Vague answers about "open communication" score poorly. If you want to practise the questions, the free leading people question bank has the common ones.
Referees matter even more. In our experience the most useful reference questions about people skills are not "Were they good with people?" Everyone says yes to that. They are questions like:
The last one is the strongest single signal we know of. Our guide to reference check questions covers the wider set. It is also worth remembering that informal references happen whether you arrange them or not. At senior level someone on the panel usually knows someone who worked with you.
You can run this now. For each statement, score yourself 1 (rarely true), 2 (sometimes true) or 3 (usually true). Be strict. The aim is to find your weakest skill, not to feel good.
Group your scores in pairs: questions 1 and 2 for listening, 3 for reading a room, 4 and 5 for feedback, 6 and 7 for trust, 8 and 9 for disagreement, and 10 to 12 for developing others. The lowest pair is the one to work on first. If two or more pairs score 3 or below out of 6, the gap is likely to show in your next senior hiring process.
A self-check has a clear limit. It measures how you see yourself, and most senior people rate their own people skills higher than their colleagues do. That is why a structured profile is useful alongside it.
The Leadership Psychometric is a 50-question leadership profile built by executive recruiters. It scores five dimensions: Vision Thinking, Execution Drive, Influencing Power, People Intelligence and Composure. People Intelligence is the dimension that sits closest to the six skills above. It covers how you read other people, how you respond to their needs and how you balance relationships against results.
Two of the other dimensions matter here too. Influencing Power affects whether your listening and trust turn into agreement. Composure affects whether you can give hard feedback and disagree without damage when you are under pressure yourself. A high People Intelligence score with low Composure often shows up as a leader who is excellent with people on a good day and short with them on a bad one.
The profile takes 10 to 15 minutes. You can take the free Leadership Psychometric and see where People Intelligence sits against your other four dimensions. If you would like to see what the five dimensions cover first, the Leadership Psychometric overview explains each one.
Free assessment
The Leadership Psychometric takes 10 to 15 minutes and reveals your five core leadership traits and where you rank against senior professionals in your market.
Take the assessment →There is a version of strong people skills that hurts senior leaders. It looks like this: you are so good at reading the room and keeping relationships smooth that you avoid the hard call. Decisions wait for consensus. Difficult feedback is softened until it carries no message. The team likes you, and performance drifts.
Panels watch for this. A candidate who describes every conflict as resolved through "bringing people together" will be asked, sooner or later, about a time they made a decision most of the room did not want. If you cannot answer that, your people skills start to look like a way of avoiding cost rather than a strength.
The balance is the point. The six skills above are about working through people to get results, not about being liked. A leader who is respected by people who disagree with them has better people skills than one who is liked by everyone.
People skills improve through repeated practice in real situations, not through courses alone. A simple plan works better than a broad goal.
Senior people also gain a lot from someone who will speak for them in rooms they are not in. That relationship depends heavily on trust and on developing others, and it is covered in this week's guide to mentor vs sponsor. If you want a sense of how People Intelligence fits alongside the ability to set direction, the companion piece on visionary leadership looks at the Vision Thinking side of the same profile.
For more on how senior leaders build and test their capabilities, see the full Leadership collection.
JOH Partners Intelligence
Get the fortnightly brief on GCC careers, salaries, and market moves.
No spam. Unsubscribe any time.
Free assessment
The Leadership Psychometric takes 10 to 15 minutes and reveals your five core leadership traits and where you rank against senior professionals in your market.
Take the assessment →More from JOH Partners
JOH Partners · ~8 min
LeadershipJOH Partners · 9 min read
LeadershipJOH Partners · 9 min read