How to Become a CFO
Three Routes From Finance Director and the Gaps That Stall People Short of the Seat

The key insight:

Most finance directors are ready for the numbers side of the CFO seat years before they are ready for the people and investor side. The stall is almost never technical.

The finance director seat is where the CFO question becomes real. You run the function, you sign off the numbers and you sit in the room when the chief executive talks about the next three years. The step to the top finance job looks short from there, and for many people it turns out to be the longest of their career. This guide is for the financial controller, FP&A head or finance director who wants to know what the route looks like, which parts are technical and which are not, and what to fix first.

A CV records what you have closed, reported and reconciled. A CFO appointment is a bet on what you will do with a balance sheet, an investor base and a team of senior people, so the evidence that matters looks forward. If you want an outside view of your leadership profile before a board forms its own, you can take the free Leadership Psychometric, a 50-question leadership profile scoring five dimensions.

Where finance directors actually start

Most CFOs began in one of three places: audit or technical accounting, a commercial finance or FP&A role close to the business, or a change or transformation seat that rebuilt a finance function. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics, in its Occupational Outlook Handbook entry for financial managers, lists a bachelor's degree and five years or more of experience in a related occupation as typical, and says experienced financial managers may advance to chief financial officer. That is the entry floor. What decides the next step is which of the three starting points you came from, because each one leaves a different gap.

Three routes to the CFO seat

No route is faster. The technical route is the most common in listed and regulated businesses because the audit committee sees an immediately safe pair of hands. The commercial route tends to win in businesses where the chief executive wants a partner. The transformation route wins when the next three years are about change. Choose the route that matches the CFO profile your target employer will actually need, and be honest about which gap it leaves.

Does the qualification still matter?

It matters less than it did and more than people say. A professional accountancy qualification is still the default in listed and regulated businesses, and for the technical route it is close to a precondition. In commercial and private-equity-backed settings, a strong operating record with a degree and an MBA, or none, is routinely accepted. The practical test is who signs off your credibility. If the audit committee chair needs to be comfortable with you on day one, hold the qualification. If the chief executive and the investors need to be, show the decisions you supported and the capital you helped raise.

The professional bodies treat each step towards the top as a development stage in its own right. ICAEW, for example, runs a six-month Network of Finance Leaders programme for senior finance professionals preparing for Finance Director roles, which is a reminder that the jump in scope is real and is usually learned, not assumed.

What the audit committee and the board look for

A first-time CFO is rarely chosen for technical depth, because the board assumes it. The questions behind the choice are different.

Can you be trusted with the truth? The CFO is the person who tells the board what the numbers say when nobody wants to hear it. Evidence of having done that, and being thanked later, counts for more than a clean record.

Can you partner with the chief executive? A finance chief who only reports is a weaker asset than one who shapes strategy. Boards look for instances where you changed a decision before it was made.

Do investors, lenders or owners trust you? Credibility with the people who provide the capital is the part of the job a finance director has least chance to practise.

Can you lead beyond finance? The role touches procurement, technology, tax, treasury and often the whole business case for a transformation. A CFO is a general manager with a finance title.

JOH Partners' view of the role is consistent with this. Its note on what makes a successful CFO treats stewardship, cash flow and controls as the technical floor, and the move to strategic business partner as the step that separates great finance chiefs from competent ones.

The gaps that keep finance directors from the seat

1. No investor or owner exposure. Ask to prepare and present the results narrative to investors, lenders or the owner, not only the numbers behind it.
2. No capital or transaction experience. The Bureau of Labor Statistics notes that treasurers and finance officers oversee plans to raise capital and develop plans for mergers and acquisitions. If you have never worked on a refinancing, a bond, a listing or an acquisition, volunteer for one.
3. No seat at the strategy table. Offer a view on the plan before the budget is built, not after, and be visible for the quality of the view.
4. A leadership profile that has never been tested outside finance. Our guide to leadership blind spots covers the patterns that are hardest to see from inside a function, and our guide to how to get promoted covers the internal case.

Is the leadership side as ready as the technical side?

Most finance directors know their technical record very well and their leadership profile far less well. A structured profile gives you an outside view of the second.

The Leadership Psychometric is a 50-question leadership profile across five dimensions:

• Vision Thinking: how naturally you set direction and see beyond the current plan.
• Execution Drive: how reliably you turn direction into delivery.
• Influencing Power: how well you move people who do not report to you, including a chief executive, a chair or an investor.
• People Intelligence: how accurately you read and develop others.
• Composure: how steady you are when the pressure is highest.

Read it as a map of where a board is likely to probe. A finance director strong on Execution Drive and thin on Influencing Power knows what to build before a chair does the comparison. The profile requires a free account, so create one and take the free Leadership Psychometric. If you would like to see what it covers first, the public overview page sets it out.

The Gulf: government-related groups and the listing pipeline

In the Gulf, finance chief hiring is shaped by two forces. At government-related entities and sovereign-linked groups, the finance chief often works to a board and a sponsor, and the weight falls on governance, reporting discipline and delivery of a mandate. Where businesses are preparing to list, the role shifts towards investor relations, capital markets and readiness for public scrutiny, and candidates with that experience are scarce. If you are weighing a move into this market, our benchmark of what a CFO is paid in Dubai and the UAE and our guide to finance director pay show where each step sits, and the wider Career Strategy collection covers the route in more detail.

The finance route sits alongside the general-management one. If your longer-term aim is the chief executive seat, our guide to how to become a CEO covers the four routes in and what boards test.

Key takeaways

• There are three routes to the CFO seat: technical, commercial and transformation. Each proves something and leaves a gap.
• The qualification matters most on the technical route and in listed or regulated businesses. Elsewhere the track record carries more weight.
• Boards look for four things beyond technical skill: truthfulness, partnership with the chief executive, credibility with capital providers and leadership range beyond finance.
• The four common gaps are no investor exposure, no capital or transaction experience, no seat at the strategy table and an untested leadership profile.
• Test the leadership side against evidence. The free Leadership Psychometric is a 50-question profile across Vision Thinking, Execution Drive, Influencing Power, People Intelligence and Composure.

JOH Partners Intelligence

Get the fortnightly brief on GCC careers, salaries, and market moves.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.